Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Blue Devil Knight on Penelope Maddy's new book


At 7/23/2008 08:07:00 AM , Blogger Blue Devil Knight said...

Thanks, Victor.

The book I reviewed, for those who don't click on the title of Victor's post, is called Second Philosophy (obviously a jab at Descartes' First Philosophy).

I got her book after the debate a few posts back on logic. In addition to her methodological views, she has a very interesting perspective on the ontology of logic, different from what I advocate. Hers is obviously more nuanced, educated in the literature, and generally well thought out, even if not necessarily correct.

At 7/24/2008 11:50:00 AM , Blogger Darek Barefoot said...


I will not have any time soon to read Maddy's book. However, maybe her thought as it specifically relates to the AfR can be summarized. I should be better read on all this than I am, however, I found the following brief exchange on the subject in general to be interesting:



At the very least it seems to confirm that naturalism and realism regarding logical necessity do not sit well together. Something that our exchange might be taken to illustrate as well.

At 7/25/2008 12:49:00 AM , Blogger Blue Devil Knight said...

You would like the book, especially parts I and III. It brings an appropriate level of precision to the discussion. She discusses examples in which (classical) logic will and will not work, that sort of thing. She also has a good deal of interesting psychological data that she brings to bear on the question of the ontogeny of logical thought (and she also relates these psychological structures to the question of the ontology of logical claims, whether they reflect general structures of the world, and if so, how general).

Anyway, you'll like the book. Maddy is good. If I do any more summarizing, review of it, it will be at that other web site.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home